power to the people
March 13th, 2008 - Posted by: vanessaThere was a great NY Tech Meetup last week that got me thinking about collective organizing. For the first time the NY Tech Meetup had a theme, “Power to the People: The Future of Organizing.” It’s exciting to see great new ideas promoting people power – and forums that uncover and celebrate their budding existence online.
It was especially appropriate that Meetup identified this as a theme, being huge innovators in the world of local, do-it-yourself organizing. For anyone who isn’t familiar with it, Meetup is a website with an elegantly simple premise: let people post an idea for a community meeting about anything – whether it’s saving the earth, starting a business, or knitting – and allow interested people in the area to attend. In hosting this event, the NY Tech Meetup (run by Scott Heiferman, the co-founder and CEO of Meetup) aimed to bring kindred spirits in the online world of organizing together.
The seeming legendary Clay Shirky was there to chat about Here Comes Everybody, “a book about organizing without organizations.” He made an interesting presentation, mostly about how much easier group action has become – and how often it’s happening these days. The simple fact that people with something in common can now find one another is a huge step. Philosopher William James once said “thinking is for doing.” Clay says “publishing is for acting,” meaning that publishing is increasingly used to gather and coordinate people.
Check out this excerpt from Clay’s book about Meetup here. He makes the point that Meetup groups can’t be organized top-down – being self-organized is key: “Though it seems funny for a service business, Meetup actually does best not by trying to do things on behalf of its users, but by providing a platform for them to do things for one another.” The book is brand new and promises to be an inspiring read. Update: Check him out on the Colbert Report…
A bunch of interesting online innovators presented at last week’s Meetup, but I was most excited about ThePoint. The Point is a brilliant new website run by Andrew Mason in Chicago that’s based on a few basic principles: (1) People want to stand up for themselves and their beliefs (2) standing up for yourself is usually a waste of time, because you’re just one person and it’s hard to be heard, and (3) people don’t want to waste their time. So he figures that people are generally being pretty rational when they skip out on standing up for themselves.
Here’s how his site solves the problem. Say you love KFC, but you want them to treat their chickens a little better. You don’t want to boycott the place by yourself, which would certainly deprive you of that deep fried goodness without much chance of sending a strong message to KFC. So you head to ThePoint, sign in to the “Tough Love for KFC” campaign:
“KFC, your chicken is so tasty. Your biscuits are so buttery. Your colonel is so regal. You’re hard not to like. But maybe you could be just a little nicer to your animals?”
And you pledge to stop eating there if KFC doesn’t adopt the suggestions of their animal welfare board only if 1,000,000 join the movement.
Now you know you won’t be forgoing those tasty morsels for naught. You can assume your actions are sure to mean something when pooled with a million like-minded souls. So ThePoint allows you to be sure the conditions exist for your actions to be meaningful.
But this tool is not confined to social movements – you can use it to make anything happen that requires cooperation. For example, you can use it to organize your neighbors to build a new community garden, only if 1,000 of them pledge $10 each to pay for it. Pretty cool. PledgeBank, a UK-based site, provides a service that’s similar to ThePoint.
This whole people-powered online revolution thing seems to have caught on in the news this week as well. There’s an interesting article in the Guardian, “People power transforms the web in next online revolution.” Like Clay’s book, the article looks at how we are going to organize ourselves “without the trappings of traditional organizations.” It talks about flash mobs – when a group of people gathers somewhere to do something random together, like smile in October Square in Belarus. Flash mobs have affected elections in Spain, Philippines, and South Korea. In China, flash mobs are staging campaigns despite 54,000 cyber police, and it seems it will soon be impossible for even the most totalitarian governments to stop people from organizing. Update 4/16/08: Check out this story about a student twittering his way out of jail in Egypt! The article also discusses Wikipedia and other movements to make information openly accessible, including the Encyclopedia of Life (about all the Earth’s species) and the Public Library of Science, an open-access journal.![]()
At MixedInk, we certainly plan to play our part in helping folks self-organize and harness their collective power. We just came up with an exciting idea that could make our democracy a little more people powered, which we submitted to the NetSquared Mashup Contest. It’s called Government by the people. You can help us win by voting for us! Anyone can register as a NetSquared user, making them eligible to vote – the contest is being decided, appropriately, by the people.
Update 4/16/08: Check out Seth Godin’s interesting article on the power of organizing.






March 13th, 2008 at 9:19 am
Thanks for the plug for PledgeBank, Vanessa. Just to clarify, we’re a bit different from The Point, in that we focus on small, community-oriented pledges (i.e. “I will clean up Sligo Creek in Takoma Park, MD, but only if 10 of my neighbors will do the same”), rather than large, corporate-focused pledges. I’d encourage folks to check out the site, and to pledge to get something done in your community!
March 13th, 2008 at 10:18 am
Hi Heather,
Thanks for highlighting the difference between the two sites. It’s great to see such innovative ways to get people together so they can accomplish what they couldn’t have done alone. Very exciting.
-Vanessa
April 4th, 2008 at 12:03 am
In several countries, people power doesn’t always work. I found some case where the leader of the group are easy to be bribed and in turn it affect the whole peoples movement.
April 14th, 2008 at 7:25 am
Absolutely, that’s true. But the power of the internet in the hands of many, many people makes that kind of corruption increasingly difficult to conceal – and therefore more difficult for leaders to get away with it.
April 15th, 2008 at 11:34 pm
Agree with you…Internet give the same chance for all people to get the whole information. But the problem, in some developing countries internet is still an exclusive thing.
April 16th, 2008 at 11:41 am
True, but check out the story I just added to the post about the student twittering his way out of jail in Egypt after being arrested for photographing a demonstration. An internet connection certainly makes things easier, but cell phones provide amazing connectivity and are ubiquitous even in places that lack widespread internet access.
May 2nd, 2008 at 3:23 am
Vanessa, this time I must say totally agree with you…Almost all people even who comes from low economics level have cellular phones.
July 31st, 2008 at 7:49 pm
Very interesting. ThePoint sounds like it resolves the “volunteers dilemma” I read about in some game theory book. Applied to boycotting, it’s the idea that unilateral boycotting punishes yourself more than your intended victim. ThePoint allows zero self-punishment unless and until the victim is majorly punished.